Home | Contact | Links       
Antonie Pannekoek Archives

 de | en | es | fr | it | nl

Period of Transition

Titlepage of the first German edition of 1930

Period of Transition

Quelle: Kommunistischer Arbeiter : Organ der Kommunistischen Arbeiter-Union, Wirtschaftbezirk Ostsachsen (Revolutionäre Betriebsorganisationen). – Jg. 1 (1932), Nr. 8 (Dezember)

de | Thema: Die ökonomische Lösung für die Übergangsperiode vom Kapitalismus zum Kommunismus
en | Theme: The Economic Solution for the Period of Transition from Capitalism to Communism
es | Tema: La solución económica para el período de transición del capitalismo al comunismo
fr | Thème : La solution économique pour la période de transition du capitalisme vers le communisme
it | Tema: La soluzione economica per il periodo di transizione dal capitalismo al comunismo
nl | Thema: De economische oplossing voor de overgangsperiode van kapitalisme naar communisme

An editorial introduction

The book by Jan Appel, in the 1935 Dutch second edition, might be edited in other languages. In Dutch, it was republished in 1950 and in 1972, but without efforts to make it available in other languages, and there were little means neither. This edition integrated at least six texts (leaving out large parts, here to be found in full), all or mostly written by Jan Appel himself in German, and partially translated:

  1. Marx-Engels und Lenin : Über die Rolle des Staates in der proletarischen Revolution / Max Hempel [=Jan Appel] (1927, also in en, fr and nl)
  2. Aantekeningen over communistische economie / door Piet de Bruin [Jan Appel], 1928, discovered in 2017, probably written in German and first published in Proletarier, an item which remains to be discovered.
  3. Bedarfswirtschaft (1929).
  4. Grundprinzipien kommunistischer Produktion und Verteilung (1930, also in en, fr, it, es and nl)
  5. Die Ausgangspunkte der Grundprinzipien kommunistischer Produktion und Verteilung (1931, also in en, fr, it and es and nl)
  6. Die gesellschaftlich-durchschnittliche Arbeitszeit als Grundlage der kommunistischen Produktion und Verteilung (1935, also in fr)

If you want to participate in making a new edition, first in German (there is a lot of comparing and editing to do, but very little to translate), then in English, and then in as many languages as possible, please contact us. The sixth text in German has also been transcribed in March 2020, thus the six texts might now be integrated into a new German edition in the wordings of Jan Appel himself, which, in turn, might serve for further translation, also based on partial already existing translations into English, Spanish, French and Italian (notably the first two items; and it seems a good idea to respect the work already done). The English translator also made interesting changes in the text, which could be marked in editorial remarks (in all languages); furthermore his no less than 90 pages of annotations have not yet been taken into account.

Here, quality is more important than speed. And some knowledge about the history of the text is desirable to approach some more “definite” edition, which unlikely will appear on paper before having been published on the web.

For as far as known, it started with: Aantekeningen over communistische economie / door Piet de Bruin [Jan Appel], 1928, discovered in 2017, probably written in German and first published in Proletarier, an item which remains to be discovered. Followed in 1929 by Bedarfswirtschaft. In 1930 a second German edition was published (known as the first edition), with a complement in 1931. These two were integrated into a new Dutch edition published in 1931. In 1935, two further contributions were integrated into a new Dutch edition; the first published in German in 1927 (Dutch in 1932), the second in 1935 (exclusively in German, no Dutch version is known, but it was translated towards French).

In 1970, a German reprint was made – including the 1930 edition, and the 1931 complement; seperately, not integrated  – and without the other contributions, and without refering to the extended 1935 edition; and this 1970 German reprint served for translations towards English, French, Italian and Spanish; it also included an introduction by Paul Mattick, which can hardly be ignored (and which is already available in de, en, es, fr,  it, and nl).

Finally, the pamphlet by Henk Canne Meijer, written in 1938, and rewritten in 1948, republished in 1972 (a close comparison between these versions remains to be made), the last version is already available in de, en, fr, and nl), should be considered to be an integral part of the work.

As many as possible original materials can be found here for further editing, and the research goes on; no © is claimed, some honesty is appreciated.

 Furthermore, for a new paper-edition (with an inevitably very limited circulation), it seems desirable to give some credit to the persons who have contributed, like Jan Appel himself, to Henk Canne Meijer (and Herman de Beer, someone completely forgotten), and to previous translators and editors. It might also be fairly annotated. And it can hardly be seen as a shame to refer to this page neither.

The already available materials (in five languages; Spanish was added as a sixth in January 2021) permit a very serious discussion; and they might be studied within the context of so many other contributions already available.

de | Übersicht

Grundprinzipien kommunistischer Produktion und Verteilung : Kollektivarbeit der Gruppe Internationaler Kommunisten (Holland), 1930. Einleitung von Paul Mattick. – Berlin-Wilmersdorf : Rüdiger Blankertz Verlag (Institut für Praxis und Theorie des Rätekommunismus), 1970. – 176 S. – S. 4-144.

Quelle: Kollektion a.a.a.p.

 Umschl., Einl., S. i-xvii, 1-3  Kap. II-III, S. 26-43  Kap. VI-VIII, S. 62-91  Kap. XV-XIX, S. 120-149
 Vorw., Inhalt, Kap. I, S. 4-25  Kap. IV-V, S. 44-61  Kap. IX-XIV, S. 92-119  Ausgangsp., p. 150-176

en | Overview

Fundamental Principles of Communist Production and Distribution / Collective Work of the Group of International Communists of Holland (g.i.c.) : [On the cover: by Jan Appel]. – London : Movement for Worker’s Councils, 1990. – xii, 589 p.

 Cover, Pref., Ch. I, p. 1-33  Ch. X-XIX, p. 141-212  Appendix I-III, p. 339-399  Notes (3), p. 535-589
 Ch. II-V, p. 34-86  Postscript (1), p. 213-273  Notes (1), p. 400-466  
 Ch. VI-IX, p. 87-140  Postscript (2), p. 274-338  Notes (2), p. 467-534  

Source pdf’s: Collection a.a.a.p.; an earlier partial English web-version html from the same source appeared on Kurasje, then disappeared, and reappeared at marxist.org , html markup by Jonas Holmgren, further edited here.

es | Visión de conjuncto

Principios fundamentales de una producción y distribución comunista (1976)

 Forro, p. 1-35  p. 36-75  p. 76-113  p. 114-143  p. 144-182 + Indice
  • es | Principios fundamentales de una producción y distribución comunista (1976)
  • es | Introducción (Paul Mattick, 1970)

fr | Aperçu

 Fondements de l’économie communiste. – Paris : Informations Correspondance Ouvrières (i.c.o.), 1971. – 48 p.

L’i.c.o. annonce en 1971 la publication d’une traduction à partir de l’allemand du livre du 1930 avec le complément de 1931, mais qui, à notre connaissance, n’a jamais été publié. Un manuscrit qui circulait à Paris à été conservé sous forme de photocopie à Bruxelles. Apparement ignorant l’existence de cette traduction à partir de l’allemand, (Dis)continuïté a publié en 2011 une nouvelle traduction vers le français à partir de la traduction anglaise “amélioré” de 1990.

Fondements de la production et de la distribution communistes (1930)  Points de départ des principes fondamentaux de la production et de la distribution communistes (1931). – [Manuscrit dactylographié, i.c.o., 1971].

 Ch. I (16 p.)  Ch. IV-V (17 p.)  Ch. IX-XII (28 p.)  Points de départ (26 p.)
 Ch. II-III (16 p.)  Ch. VI-VIII (28 p.)  Ch. XIII-XIX (28 p.)  

 Fondements de la production et de la distribution communiste. Groupe de Communistes Internationaux (g.i.c. 1930) ; Préface de Paul Mattick. – Brochure pdf mise en ligne par La Bataille socialiste  en 2014. – 134 p.; édition d’après i.c.o., 1971, voir plus haut, avec des annexes.
Contient :

it | Sondaggio

Principi fondamentali di produzione e di distribuzione comunista / Gruppo comunisti internazionali olandesi (g.i.c.h.), Introduzione di Paul Mattick. – Milano : Coop. Edizione Jaca Book, 1974. – 234 p.

 Introduzione; p. 1-31  Ch. II.-IV., p. 65-104  Ch. VII. X., p. 134-178  Ch. XVI.-XIX., p. 202-234
 Intro, Ch. I, p. 32-64  Ch. V.-VI., p. 105-133  Ch. XI.-XV., p. 179-201  

  • it |  Introduzione (Paul Mattick, 1970)

nl | Overzicht

© Allthough the Communist Left in general abstained from claiming copyrights or rights on “intellectuel property”, some publications on this site might be copyrighted; if they are, their use is free for personal consultation only. Non-copyrighted material, provided for non-commercial use only, can be freely distributed. Including a reference to this source is appreciated, as well as a notification. As for commercial use, please contact us.

© Bien que, en général, la Gauche communiste s’abstenait d’exiger des droits d’auteur ou des droits de “propriété intellectuelle”, certaines publications de ce site pourraient être protégées par de tels droits. Si c’est le cas, leur accès est gratuit seulement pour consultation d’ordre privé. Le matériel non protégé par ces droits peut être librement diffusé pour tout usage non commercial. Nous vous serions reconnaissants de référencier vos sources et de les accompagner d’un avertissement. Pour une utilisation à but lucratif, prière de prendre contact.

© Obgleich die Kommunistische Linke im Allgemeinen keine Urheberrechte bzw. “intellektuelle Eigentumsrechte” für sich eingefordert hat, können einige Veröffentlichungen auf dieser Webseite urheberrechtlich geschützt sein. In diesem Fall steht ihr Gebrauch nur zum Zweck persönlichen Nachschlags frei. Ungeschütztes Material kann für nicht-kommerzielle Zwecke frei und unentgeltlich verbreitet werden. Wir sind Ihnen erkenntlich für Ihren Quellenhinweis und Benachrichtigung. Bei beabsichtigter kommerzieller Nutzung bitten wir um Kontaktaufnahme.

© Hoewel de Communistische Linkerzijde in het algemeen afzag van het opeisen van kopierechten of rechten op “intellectueel eigendom” kunnen sommige publicaties onder dat recht vallen; mocht dat het geval zijn, dan is het gebruik alleen gratis voor persoonlijke raadpleging. Materiaal vrij van kopierechten, uitsluitend op voorwaarde van niet commercieel gebruik, kan vrij worden verspreid. Een verwijzing naar deze bron wordt op prijs gesteld, net als een verwittiging. Aangaande handelsgebruik kunt u contact met ons opnemen.

Compiled by Vico, 6 January 2016, latest additions 2 November 2021